Gold vs. Gold Miners: A Comparison

Jul 9 18:23

Gold prices have been hitting record highs with rising inflation and geopolitical tensions.

Naturally, this has shone a spotlight on all things gold-related, from futures and ETFs to gold mining stocks.

But here's the kicker: while gold prices are soaring, some gold mining stocks aren't keeping up.

Why the disconnect, and how can you navigate this golden maze? Let's break it down.

Takeaways:

  • Despite record-high gold prices, some gold mining stocks haven't kept pace.

  • Various factors influence miners' performance, and the All-in Sustaining Costs (AISC) is a key metric for assessing operational efficiency.

  • A deeper insight into the companies is essential for investing in gold miners compared to following gold prices solely.

article image

1. Gold Miners aren't always Golden

Typically, gold mining stocks offer greater leverage than gold itself. This isn't unique to gold; it's common in commodities.

For example, oil company stocks usually fluctuate more than crude oil prices, and the same goes for companies dealing in copper or aluminum.

This is because mining companies operate with higher leverage, needing massive investments in equipment and operations.

Plus, stock prices are often driven by investor sentiment and market expectations, making them even more volatile.

However, this time around, the script has flipped. In the current gold bull run, mining stocks are lagging.

Take Newmont Mining (NEM) and Barrick Mining (B), which rank among the top two in the world in terms of production:

Note: Barrick changed its stock ticker to B, rather than the more recognizable GOLD, in May 2025.

From early 2024 to May 2025, gold prices shot up over 60%, Newmont only climbed about 30%, and Barrick barely hit a 10% rise.

2. The All-in Sustaining Costs (AISC)

Running a mining company is far more complex than just riding the wave of commodity price changes.

Various factors affect a mining company's performance, including the location of the mines, mining conditions, and management leadership.

For instance, open-pit mines are cheaper to operate than underground mines, and mines in North America and Europe typically have better infrastructure and stability than those in politically unstable regions like parts of Africa.

Even among mining stocks, performance varies significantly. Agnico Eagle Mines (AEM), a Canadian-based company, saw its stock price more than double in the same period.

article image
Source: moomoo. Data as of May 9, 2025.
Investing involves risk and the potential to lose principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This is for information and illustrative purposes only. It should not be relied on as advice or a recommendation.

To evaluate a mining company's prowess, consider its All-in Sustaining Costs (AISC).

This metric covers not just production costs but everything needed to keep operations running—capital expenditures, exploration, and environmental management.

For example, Barrick's AISC soared from $1,000 per ounce in 2020 to $1,775 by the first quarter of 2025, an increase in cost of nearly 80%. In contrast, AEM's AISC was under $1,200 by early 2025.

article image

Only a few companies like AEM have been able to achieve such significant excess returns due to their competitive cost structures.

Since 2016, the discount of gold mining stocks relative to gold prices has continued to widen, reaching a nearly 20-year high in 2025.

article image
Source: VanEck.
Investing involves risk and the potential to lose principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This is for information and illustrative purposes only. It should not be relied on as advice or a recommendation.

3. Investing in Gold on moomoo

The data indicates that investing in gold mining stocks merits careful consideration of companies with high-quality operations and strong cost advantages.

Otherwise, there is a risk of sub-optimal market performance compared with industry peers.

If you don't have the time or resources to analyze each mining company, ETFs that track gold prices might be appropriate.

Investors can use Moomoo’s Thematic ETF feature to find related products.

Here's how: Markets > ETFs > Thematic ETFs > Gold ETFs.

article image

It's important to note that some ETFs track gold prices, while others track gold mining stocks, and some even include leverage. Be sure to evaluate your investment options based on your specific investment objectives and risk tolerance.

This presentation is for informational and educational use only and is not a recommendation or endorsement of any particular investment or investment strategy. Investment information provided in this content is general in nature, strictly for illustrative purposes, and may not be appropriate for all investors. Read more

Recommend

Why does Warren Buffett say don't piggyback on his trades?

How does nonfarm payroll impact the global market?

Unveiling Inflation: Why is Your Wallet Shrinking?

Mastering the Dollar Cycle: How to invest in a changing economy

Gold vs. Gold Miners: A Comparison

Are U.S. Treasuries still a safe haven?

Meet Dr. Copper: Understanding the Copper Market

Do Oil Price Swings Rock the Stock Market?

How Tariffs Could Impact the Copper Landscape?

Why do oil ETFs lag behind oil prices in the long run?

Why is the US dollar so powerful worldwide, and how can we tell?

A look at employment: what other indicators are there?

GDP: The Barometer of National Prosperity

Understanding Treasury Auctions: A Step-by-Step Guide

Unpacking the U.S. Debt Issue

Why is Oil Called the "Mother of All Commodities"?

How Inflation Affects the Market

How to interpret the Fed dot plot?

How to Decode Inflation: CPI, PCE, and PPI

Understanding Bessent's Fiscal Blueprint

The Rise of the Fed: Can Trump Dismiss Powell?

What's in the Fed's Toolbox?

'Oracle of Omaha' Warren Buffett:ROE>20% is preferable

'Father of value investing' Benjamin Graham: Ten Stock Selection Criteria

Strong Consumer Spending Despite Economic Slowdown: Here's Why

Analyzing the manufacturing industry may help you grasp economic trends

What is the Debt Ceiling? A Deep Dive into US Fiscal Policy

How to Preserve Your Wealth in a High Inflation Environment

How to analyze the Federal Reserve's monetary policy?

Rapidly Rising US Housing Prices: Opportunity or Risk?

How Will the US Dollar Perform in 2024? A Closer Look into the US Dollar Index

Discussing the driving forces behind rises in gold prices

Investing and Labor Market Indicators

Discover the bond market: A quick and easy guide

The Underlying Conflicts Surrounding Crude Oil Prices

Understanding the relationship between the stock market and the bond market

Understanding the US Non-Farm Payroll Data

Understanding the Federal Reserve Interest Rate Decision

Understanding the CCI

Understanding the PPI

Understanding the Retail Sales

Understanding the US Crude Oil Inventories

Understanding the Durable Goods Orders

Listen to the Fed's speakers: Hawks or doves?

Open the Fed's monetary policy toolbox

The Fed Dot Plot explained: What it says about US interest rates

How does monetary policy steer our lives and investment

What the Federal Reserve does?

Understanding the GDP

A brief history lesson on the Fed and U.S. economy

08 Carl Icahn & Icahn Enterprises

09 Seth Klarman & Baupost Group

07 Howard Marks & Oaktree Capital

01 Using 13F filings to learn from big investors

03 How to Read Form 13F

02 Identify a fund's investment strategy

04 Warren Buffett & Berkshire Hathaway

06 Ray Dalio & Bridgewater Associates

05 Bill Ackerman & Pershing Square Capital

Why does Warren Buffett say don't piggyback on his trades?

How does nonfarm payroll impact the global market?

Unveiling Inflation: Why is Your Wallet Shrinking?

Mastering the Dollar Cycle: How to invest in a changing economy

Gold vs. Gold Miners: A Comparison

Are U.S. Treasuries still a safe haven?

Meet Dr. Copper: Understanding the Copper Market

Do Oil Price Swings Rock the Stock Market?

How Tariffs Could Impact the Copper Landscape?

Why do oil ETFs lag behind oil prices in the long run?

Why is the US dollar so powerful worldwide, and how can we tell?

A look at employment: what other indicators are there?

GDP: The Barometer of National Prosperity

Understanding Treasury Auctions: A Step-by-Step Guide

Unpacking the U.S. Debt Issue

Why is Oil Called the "Mother of All Commodities"?

How Inflation Affects the Market

How to interpret the Fed dot plot?

How to Decode Inflation: CPI, PCE, and PPI

Understanding Bessent's Fiscal Blueprint

The Rise of the Fed: Can Trump Dismiss Powell?

What's in the Fed's Toolbox?

'Oracle of Omaha' Warren Buffett:ROE>20% is preferable

'Father of value investing' Benjamin Graham: Ten Stock Selection Criteria

Strong Consumer Spending Despite Economic Slowdown: Here's Why

Analyzing the manufacturing industry may help you grasp economic trends

What is the Debt Ceiling? A Deep Dive into US Fiscal Policy

How to Preserve Your Wealth in a High Inflation Environment

How to analyze the Federal Reserve's monetary policy?

Rapidly Rising US Housing Prices: Opportunity or Risk?

How Will the US Dollar Perform in 2024? A Closer Look into the US Dollar Index

Discussing the driving forces behind rises in gold prices

Investing and Labor Market Indicators

Discover the bond market: A quick and easy guide

The Underlying Conflicts Surrounding Crude Oil Prices

Understanding the relationship between the stock market and the bond market

Understanding the US Non-Farm Payroll Data

Understanding the Federal Reserve Interest Rate Decision

Understanding the CCI

Understanding the PPI

Understanding the Retail Sales

Understanding the US Crude Oil Inventories

Understanding the Durable Goods Orders

Listen to the Fed's speakers: Hawks or doves?

Open the Fed's monetary policy toolbox

The Fed Dot Plot explained: What it says about US interest rates

How does monetary policy steer our lives and investment

What the Federal Reserve does?

Understanding the GDP

A brief history lesson on the Fed and U.S. economy

08 Carl Icahn & Icahn Enterprises

09 Seth Klarman & Baupost Group

07 Howard Marks & Oaktree Capital

01 Using 13F filings to learn from big investors

03 How to Read Form 13F

02 Identify a fund's investment strategy

04 Warren Buffett & Berkshire Hathaway

06 Ray Dalio & Bridgewater Associates

05 Bill Ackerman & Pershing Square Capital

Table of contents
1. Gold Miners aren't always Golden
2. The All-in Sustaining Costs (AISC)
Market Insights
Anthropic Opens at $111.50, Up 34% From IPO Price—Can Its Debut Revive the AI Trade?
$Anthropic (ANT.US)$ opened at $111.50 on its Nasdaq debut, surging 34% above its $83 IPO price, which valued the company at approximately $1 Show More
Anthropic Ecosystem
Anthropic-themed ETF